New Study Claims Health Difference in Apple Varieties
Yesterday, the American Chemical Society (ACS) issued a press release
about a new study claiming some apple varieties have a higher level of
antioxidants and are therefore healthier than other varieties.
Since this study is beginning to attract some media coverage, we wanted
to bring it to your attention. The study, conducted by Canadian
researcher Rong Tsao, Ph.D. of Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada in
Guelph, Ontario, will be published in the ACS scientific publication,
the Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry.
The study and the ACS release are a positive for apples overall,
although certain varieties are singled out as having higher antioxidant
levels than others. Several other research studies, most recently
one by the U.S. Department of Agriculture, have reached similar
conclusions.
A copy of the ACS release is attached to this email, and it can be
found online at
--http://acswebapplications.acs.org/applications/ccs/application/index.cfm?PressReleaseID=2486&categoryid=1.
Virtually all news reports about the study mention the apple health
benefits found in recent research studies. Studies included in
the ACS release were:
• Alzheimer’s disease. In
rats, quercetin –– another potent antioxidant abundant in apples ––
appears to protect brain cells against oxidative stress, a
tissue–damaging process associated with Alzheimer’s and other
neurodegenerative disorders.
• Heart
disease. Antioxidants found in apple extracts could potentially
lower "bad" cholesterol (low density lipoprotein, or LDL) by
stimulating the production of LDL receptors in the liver, which help
remove cholesterol from the blood. This mechanism is similar to that of
statin drugs, researchers say.
• Breast cancer. Rats
exposed to a known carcinogen and then fed the human equivalent of one,
three or six apples a day respectively over 24 weeks were up to 44
percent less likely to develop breast tumors.
In addition, almost every news organization picked up this quote from
Dr. Tsao: “When taste and texture do not matter, choosing an apple with
a high proportion of polyphenols in the flesh and skin can potentially
produce more health benefits,” Tsao said. “But eating any apple is
better than eating no apple at all.”
The Toronto Globe and Mail newspaper presented another strong statement
for apples: “Apples. . . are not as rich in antioxidants as blueberries
or blackberries. They are, however, more affordable, more widely
available and more robust when it comes to storage, which means that an
apple a day may be the most effective means of ensuring a healthy dose
of antioxidants.”
Because local media organizations may try to get a local or state angle
on this story, USApple wanted to provide some “talking points” on the
overall health benefits of apples, which may be helpful if you are
contacted by media representatives on this issue.
We will continue to monitor this situation. If you have any
questions, please feel free to contact Wendy Davis
(wdavis@usapple.org), Nancy Foster (nfoster@usapple.org) or me
(sschaffer@usapple.org) via email or by calling (800) 781-4443.
-----------------------------
Talking points in response to June 2005 Journal of Agriculture and Food
Chemistry, “Certain Apples Carry a Better Health Punch than Others.”
◦ This study underscores the fact
that apples have important disease-fighting antioxidants which can
provide benefits for many diseases from Alzheimer’s disease to breast
cancer.
◦ Consumers can look to this new
research as another compelling reason to enjoy even more apples!
◦ The lead researcher highlights
the fact that ALL apples are healthy for consumers, “Eating any apple
is better than eating no apple at all,” said Dr. Rong Tsao.
◦ Along with their high
antioxidant content, apples are widely available, easy to store and
represent a great value for consumers. These attributes make
apples an outstanding option for consumers looking for a healthy dose
of antioxidants.
◦ Different apple varieties offer
consumers a choice in taste and texture in apples. They also
allow for great flexibility in the use of apples in many products.
◦ All apples and apple products
provide antioxidant quality for the prevention of chronic diseases.
◦ One apple provides the same
amount of antioxidant activity as 1,500 mg of vitamin C. This
proves that eating apples will provide more antioxidant qualities than
taking dietary supplements.
◦ Along with Alzheimer’s disease,
breast cancer and heart disease, which were all mentioned specifically
in Dr. Tsao’s study, apples may also aid in the prevention or treatment
of other illnesses, including prostrate cancer, Type II diabetes, and
asthma.
◦ There are many variables
besides variety, including maturity and ripening, that could cause
differences in antioxidant levels in apples.
◦ In addition to high levels of
antioxidants, apples are also an excellent source of fiber, which has
been found to be a health benefit for many reasons, including the
aiding in proper digestion. The latest nutrition guidelines by
the U.S. Department of Agriculture call for increased fiber consumption.


